For privately held companies eyeing a liquidity event, such as an acquisition, IPO or management buyout, identifying the optimal timing for the transaction has always been subject to a certain degree of guesswork.
Given today’s volatile markets, the conundrum certainly isn’t getting any less opaque, with 58% of senior decision-makers at private companies saying the timing of their most likely liquidity event has changed in just the past 12 months.
That’s according to a recent KPMG survey of 301 respondents holding C-suite, controller, head of financial reporting or EVP/SVP/VP roles in audit, accounting or finance. Notably, similar proportions of those polled said the time horizon has been either delayed or accelerated (22% and 18%, respectively), while 13% said a timeline was established for the first time and 5% said they no longer expected to pursue the event.
Fewer than half (43%) of survey respondents said they were prepared to execute a transaction immediately, even though 48% were confident they could shift to a different exit path without meaningful delay, additional cost or valuation erosion.
KPMG portrayed the findings as indicating a “significant execution gap.” In fact, the firm suggested in its research report that highly prioritizing the timing of a liquidity event could be a mistake. Rather, greater value can be expected for companies that have built the operational, financial, tax and technology capabilities to pursue multiple pathways without losing momentum, according to the report.
“There are a lot of companies sitting on the sidelines waiting for the perfect market window, but volatility isn’t going away,” Shari Mager, leader of KPMG’s private emerging growth advisory practice, said in a press release. “The companies that are best positioned are doing the work well before they know exactly when or how they’ll exit. That preparation gives them the ability to act when the right opportunity emerges.”
However, only 21% of survey participants said their company is preparing multiple exit pathways.
Still, more than half (53%) of respondents expressed confidence they could achieve an attractive valuation within 24 months, although results varied by industry.
A strategic sale to another company was the most common liquidity event under consideration, with 43% of the private-company leaders mulling such an exit. An additional 34% said they’re considering a sale to a private equity investor. An IPO was in the mix of paths for 16% of those surveyed.
Less-common paths included a sponsor-led recapitalization or refinancing, an employee ownership or management buyout, and a direct listing.
“The risk of a single-path plan is not only that the preferred market may close,” KPMG wrote. “A company can also begin optimizing for one outcome in ways that make alternatives more difficult or costly.”
Further, systems, reporting, governance and talent designed around one buyer profile or due diligence model may take significant time to adjust if conditions change, the report warned.