Free Subscription to CFO Magazine

CFO Blog: Commentary and Opinion

You are here: Home : CFO Blog : Is Cox on the Fast Track toward Principles-Based Accounting?

ACCOUNTING
Is Cox on the Fast Track toward Principles-Based Accounting?
Posted by David M. Katz | CFO.com | US
June 26, 2007 11:32 AM ET

At the House Financial Services Committee hearing with the five SEC commissioners that I'm listening in on today, Chairman Christopher Cox seemed to drop a piece of red-hot news.

Under questioning from Rep. John Campbell of California—who proudly revealed that he was a CPA— Cox said that the SEC will issue later this summer a concept release exploring the possibility of moving to a principles-based accounting system from the current rules-based system and whether that's possible given the nation's system of tort liability.

The question is, what will this mean? Campbell's question came in the context of a discussion of the accounting required of international companies listing on U.S. exchanges, so it's not a stretch to think that Cox is referring to a move from U.S. GAAP to international financial reporting standards, since the latter is a good deal more principles-based.

Indeed Cox actually said that the question of principles v. rules "is at the center of attention around the world" and observed that foreign companies listing here can now use IFRS. In fact, he recalled that former U.S. Fed Chairman Paul Volcker was a driving force behind the European Commission mandating of IFRS as the single set of standards throughout the EC.

Cox also testified that the SEC has been under pressure from Congress since its enactment of Sarbox in 2002 to explore how fast the country could move toward a principles-based system—on the grounds that it was a rules-based system that enabled Enron to hatch is evil doings.

What seems to have happened is that the deft chairman has arranged things so that the SEC will launch an effort in the next few weeks to put a changeover toward principles—perhaps in a form close to IFRS—on a fast track. More information on that may be coming in a press conference that Cox has called for 11:15 tomorrow. If it's true, that could be really be red-hot news.

Comments (1)


Comments | Post a Comment
I think it is dangerous for people to think that principles-based accounting will help prevent another Enron. It wasn't the accounting rules/standards that caused the problem, it was people who willingly chose to hide the truth. They used their knowledge of the rules to hide the truth. Like minded people will still be able to hide the truth under principles-based accounting. The difference will be in how they explain it.
Posted by Kevin OToole | June 27, 2007 09:50am

previous post next post
MOST RECENT POSTS
How Smart Is Business Intelligence?
Confessions of a Facebook Drop-Out
What Does Internal Audit Expect from the CFO?
The Real Moneyball
Expense-Report Approvals: No Laughing Matter
ABOUT THE CFO BLOG
FAQ
ARCHIVES
« FEBRUARY 2012 »
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29    
   
OPTIONS
Email to a Colleague
  Printer Friendly Version  
  RSS Feeds  
WE DELIVER
Newsletters
CFO Daily Briefing
CFO Weekly Briefing
Webcasts
Notify me of future events
Enter your email address to begin receiving updates on these topics.
INSIDE TODAY IN FINANCE
SEC Defends Unanimous Votes to Frank
Congresswoman Turns Up the Heat on SEC
HSBC Taps GE Exec for CFO Post
IBM Settles Equipment-leasing Charges
GlobalSantaFe Probes Nigerian Woes
Debt Vehicles Force Bus Co. to Restate
Subsidiary Rights
Browse all Today in Finance

advertisement