Free Subscription to CFO Magazine

CFO Blog: Commentary and Opinion

You are here: Home : CFO Blog : The Socialist and the Federalist

CAPITAL MARKETS
The Socialist and the Federalist
Posted by S.L. Mintz | CFO.com | US
March 25, 2009 11:33 AM ET

Who’d have predicted this headline a year ago: Seasoned Wall Street Hedge Fund Executive Endorses Dose of Socialism to Revitalize Capitalism.

But that’s the gist of a private conversation held yesterday. Speaking freely on the condition that we wouldn’t identify him, a hedge fund executive likened the current banking and credit crisis to a city on fire and a clogged highway blocking fire fighters. Don’t repair the road first, he said. Find a better route that gets water where it’s needed as fast as possible. Fix the road later.

In this case, he suggested, forget about rescuing big banks in peril. If they’re not viable, don’t throw good money after bad. Let them go, but gently. Ease their passing to avoid another Lehman Brothers shock. Reassure investors that Uncle Sam stands behind critical obligations in an orderly market.

Then use taxpayers’ money to capitalize a brand-new, pristine bank with unhampered credit capacity. It would resemble the Resolution Trust Corporation that bailed out banks and thrifts nearly two decades ago, but on a much larger, global stage. Limit its active role to two or three years, enough time to jump-start credit markets. Then wind it down until all loans are retired, say by 2019.

Who would run it? No whopping bonuses required in this scenario, says the Wall Street vet. The new bank would attract top talent motivated by nobler incentives -- an exciting job at the center of a crisis and a powerful career credential afterwards plus, of course, a “respectable” salary. But would his modest proposal survive critics in Congress with knives out for more government bureaucracy? Probably not, he concedes, "given the vicissitudes of Washington."

In any case, the solution evokes an earlier world turned upside down and the federal bank that helped restore it. In 1781, a year after Congress scrapped the worthless Continental currency, secretary of finance Robert Morris took the reins in a war-torn, fledgling nation bereft of credit. An adroit financier often vilified for his motives, Morris capitalized the Bank of North America with a dollop of private credit and a wagonload of French gold intended for empty Congressional coffers.

The Bank of North America’s earliest loans helped provision an army charged with keeping British occupiers at bay until the Revolutionary War ended. Despite regular battles against renewing its charter, the country's first chartered commercial bank remained in business for several decades while a U.S. banking system emerged around it.

As for poor Morris, signer of the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution, a mentor to Alexander Hamilton, and confidant of George Washington, kudos vanished when disastrous real estate speculation ended his public career in debtor's prison. His heirs in speculation may have it easier today.

Comments (2)


Comments | Post a Comment
Hamilton was more a mentor to Morris than the other way around. Hamilton basically worked out the fiscal policy that Morris carried out in 1781.

"The affairs of nation building were never far from his mind, however, and he returned to his musings on financial reform in a letter to Robert Morris, who had just been appointed Superintendent of Finance under the recently ratified Articles of Confederation.

Hamilton wrote to Morris in support of a strong "executive ministry," which would provide much-needed decisiveness in the governing body: "I am persuaded now it is the only resource we have to exricate ourselves from the distresses, which threaten the subversion of our cause." He pointed out the domestic and international implications of the official but still impotent congress, -- "the people have lost all confidence . . . our friends in Europe are in the same disposition," -- and, working out a favorite theme, ended his letter with a detailed plan for a national bank."

http://www.laughtergenealogy.com/bin/histprof/misc/hamiltonbio.html
Posted by Michael Martin | March 25, 2009 01:21pm


I've read the letter too. Hamilton admired Morris and like any protege shared his opinions, in considerable detail. But Morris hired Hamiliton as NY tax commissioner and later, it's widely believed, Morris demurred when Washington offered him the post as the nation'sTreasury Secretary, proposing Hamilton instead. So who was whose mentor? You could debate that on the strength of one letter. But evidence over two decades suggests otherwise, including Hamilton's lavish praise of Morris as the man to lead finance. Moreover, by preserving a national debt, Morris and his nationalist allies set the stage for Hamilton. Where Morris was hobbled as secretary of finance by a toothless articles of confederation, Hamilton operated more successfully under the more muscular aegis of a Constitution.
Posted by CFO Staff: S.L. Mintz | March 25, 2009 02:07pm

previous post next post
MOST RECENT POSTS
How Smart Is Business Intelligence?
Confessions of a Facebook Drop-Out
What Does Internal Audit Expect from the CFO?
The Real Moneyball
Expense-Report Approvals: No Laughing Matter
ABOUT THE CFO BLOG
FAQ
ARCHIVES
« FEBRUARY 2012 »
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29    
   
OPTIONS
Email to a Colleague
  Printer Friendly Version  
  RSS Feeds  
WE DELIVER
Newsletters
CFO Daily Briefing
Capital Markets/Banking
Webcasts
Notify me of future events
Enter your email address to begin receiving updates on these topics.
INSIDE TODAY IN FINANCE
Diebold Probe Costs CFO His Job
Going Under
E&Y Settles HealthSouth Case for $109M
Sharing the Pain
Browse all Today in Finance

advertisement