CFO Blog: Commentary and Opinion

You are here: Home : CFO Blog : Leading the Revolution against "Imperial CEOs"

GOVERNANCE
Leading the Revolution against "Imperial CEOs"
Posted by Roy Harris | CFO.com | US
July 9, 2008 8:56 AM ET

Gary Wilson has long been known as a corporate chairman (Northwest Airlines) and an influential board member (Yahoo, still, and Walt Disney, for 21 years, until 2006.) But to finance chiefs he'll always be one of the founders of the modern CFO-strategist role, which he played at Marriott, Disney, and Northwest. So when he writes of the need to take domineering CEO/chairmen down a peg — as he does in a Wall Street Journal op-ed piece today — he brings the perspective of a veteran CFO to the debate as well.

His article, titled "How to Rein in the Imperial CEO," points to the conflict of interest that infects the situation of the chief executive being one and the same with the board chairman — that individual charged with leading supposedly independent directors as they "hire, oversee and, if necessary, fire the CEO."

The combination post is a tool of empire-building in a company, he writes, continuing: "All too often, we also find an imperial air force of large private jets reserved for the CEO's trips to the Masters, the Super Bowl or that Paris 'business' trip."

Just the rare vestige of a bygone pre-Sarbox era, which brought the separation of CEO/chairman powers into vogue? Hardly, notes Wilson. Fully 65 percent of the S&P 500 still employ the old approach, he points out, led by heavyweights GE, Coke, Exxon Mobil, UPS, Deere, Caterpillar, J&J, and CSX.

Wilson is currently on an alternate director slate for transportation company CSX, proposed by a hedge-fund shareholder; so his thoughts about what to do there are pretty clear. But he peppers his op-ed, too, with tales about tension at Disney during the term of Michael Eisner, who had the two titles, along with that of America's favorite family TV-show host. And Wilson praises Yahoo for separating the posts, while also suggesting that the Yahoo board will produce "a good outcome" in any dealings with Microsoft and others.

If lots of ex-executives these days are proving F. Scott Fitzgerald wrong as they perform their virtuoso "second acts," 68-year-old Gary Wilson is showing that a CFO can be influential in the third act, as well.

Comments (2)


Comments | Post a Comment
Mr. Wilson makes some good points about the control some CEO?s exercise over their Boards as Chairman and CEO. I doubt, however, if splitting the Chairman CEO role will really change the imperial CEO?s influence.

The Chairman and CEO is imperial because of his personality and ability to control the agenda, not the fact that his title is Chairman and CEO.

I am not concerned about who is Chairman or who is CEO or if they are one and the same. I can?t change the fact that the CEO is a strong charismatic personality. What can be changed is who is setting the agenda for Board discussion. The person who drives the agenda drives the Board.

Every Board should have an agenda committee. The committee should consist of the strongest two independent directors and the CEO. The Chairman of the agenda committee should be an independent Director, not the CEO. This arrangement should at least insure that the right issues are being brought to the Board.

If the Board, at that point, doesn?t have the backbone to stand up to the CEO, shareholders need to replace the Board or sell their stock and invest in another company. As the stock price falls, the Board and CEO will get the message.

By the way, the imperial CEO is generally the CEO who leads a company into shareholder and S.E.C. lawsuits. What was the Chairman/CEO role at Enron, WorldCom, Tyco and HealthSouth?
Posted by Dave Guenthner | July 09, 2008 01:51pm

need a 'CFO' for the company (Hourglass Investors), please send CV's to: info@hgi.ae
Posted by latif ahmed | August 17, 2008 08:27am

previous post next post
MOST RECENT POSTS
Feds Fumble Whistleblower Protection
Freudian Slip-up?
Is There an IFRS Resistance Movement?
SEC: Unfashionably Late for the Online Party
Whose Accounting is Stricter?
ABOUT THE CFO BLOG
FAQ
ARCHIVES
« SEPTEMBER 2008 »
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30     
   
OPTIONS
Email to a Colleague
  Printer Friendly Version  
Get Blog Alerts
  RSS Feeds  
WE DELIVER
Newsletters
This Week in Finance
Today in Finance
Webcasts
Notify me of future events
Email Alerts
Regulatory Issues
Enter your email address to begin receiving updates on these topics.
INSIDE TODAY IN FINANCE
How Fair Value Rewards Deadbeats
A Little Fair Value Never Killed Anyone
Sycamore Ex-CFO Settles Backdating Case
Should Monolines Blame Mark-to-market?
Spinning a New Web
Which Cities Rule in Building Net Worth?
Insider-trade Probe Hits Ex-Airbus CFO
From Omaha to the Alps
Browse all Today in Finance

advertisement