It is clear that making it to CFO — and beyond — takes a special determination. "Women who are seriously interested in being CEOs can't stay in finance their whole careers," says Klein, "and they've got to fight for those [outside] roles." To facilitate the process, Klein, along with the company's general counsel and vice president of marketing (both women), recently started a companywide network of senior women to help develop women as leaders. "It's important for us to help them move around," says Klein, who has worked at more than five companies in her quest to get a broad range of experiences. Similar networks exist at companies like IBM, Intel, and Fortune Brands.
Men Behaving Nicely
Despite the small numbers, many women claim they have never felt stigmatized by gender. "Being a female has had no impact on my career at all," says Reed, adding that more than half of her direct reports are women. "I don't think gender is an important factor."
Some women would argue that point. One-third of women in finance believe they have been denied a promotion in the past five years at least partly because of gender, according to CFO's survey. Even companies that have worked hard to promote equality report that it is a slow slog. At GE/NBC Universal, Calpeter notes that the number of women in finance drops from about 45 percent at the entry level to the "high teens" in senior roles.
It's not just the CEO who presents a barrier, either. Finance departments tend to be largely male, which colors the environment. Although Marathon Oil CFO Janet Clark says she doesn't feel "held back" by gender, the frequent sports discussions leave her a bit cold. And the double standard hasn't altogether disappeared. "Where a man might be considered assertive, a woman is pushy," Clark points out. Ovation Products Corp. CFO Christine Cox agrees. "You get incredible pushback as CFO," she says, "and it takes a lot of endurance to maintain a strong presence over time."
But anyone eager to subscribe to a corporate conspiracy against women will be disappointed. Men apparently have a fairly rosy view of what women can do. Most who responded to CFO's survey — 62 percent — don't think women are at a disadvantage in any areas relevant to becoming CFO. Only 2 percent believe women lack the financial skills to become CFO, and few think they are less able to negotiate, gain the trust of the CEO, or communicate with the board.
In fact, the one disadvantage men attribute to women is one with which women agree: 25 percent of both male and female respondents think women are unwilling to sacrifice their personal lives for work. "The question these days is, Who is willing to be a workaholic?" says Bob Loveman, CEO of wealth-management firm Brownson, Rehmus & Foxworth, and the husband of former Beatrice Foods treasurer Gail Loveman. "Typically, the answer is men, and single women under a certain age who are trying to build up enough money before bailing out."
In practice, women say they work almost as many hours per week as their male counterparts — 50.7 hours on average, as compared with 53.4 for men. Meanwhile, examples of dedication abound. One rising controller actually rescheduled her wedding three times because of her work.
What feeds the perception that women work less, says Sylvia Hewlett, director of the Center for Work-Life Policy (CWLP), is that "most women don't follow a lockstep, linear career path like men." Nearly 40 percent of highly qualified women take a year or two off during their careers, according to research by CWLP, while many others look for reduced responsibilities or flexible arrangements in order to meet multiple demands. In CFO's survey, nearly twice as many women as men said flexible hours and remote work opportunities were important to them.
Obviously, child-rearing plays a huge role. Diane Price Baker left her job as CFO of The New York Times Co. in 1999 when she became pregnant with twins two years after adopting her first child at age 43. She felt that "if having kids was important, it was time to focus on that," she says. Baker had no trouble finding another CFO job when her children started school, but she left it a year later. "The hours eat you alive," she says of the combination of overseeing the finances of a French-owned Atari subsidiary and three small children. She is now looking for a position as a turnaround expert or a private-equity partner where she can have a strategic role "but not be stuck writing checks every day."
Even past child-rearing years, women tend to factor in other priorities when making choices about their jobs. Leara L. Dory, vice president of accounting, treasurer, and controller for a $900 million division of Emcor Group, passed up an opportunity to be considered for the divisional CFO slot in 2004 for fear that she would have to work more than her typical 12-hour day. Although her only son has left the nest, she still wants time to spend with her husband of 19 years. "I knew I could do the job," Dory says, "but my main issue was to balance work and life."
Sometimes the search for a better balance has little to do with family and more to do with exploring career options beyond finance. Edwina Woodbury, 54, left Avon in December 1998, and bought a vanity press in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, which she now runs. Gail Lieberman, former CFO of Thomson Corp.'s Professional and Publishing Group, resigned to start a consulting and investment business in 2001, because "I really wanted to try something different, and I could afford it," she says. Others have taken on board seats and become audit-committee chairs, including former Barnes & Noble CFO Irene Miller; Blythe McGarvie, former CFO of Hannaford Brothers and BIC Group; Debra Smithart-Oglesby, former CFO of Brinker International; and former RR Donnelley CFO Cheryl Francis.






Reader CommentsDisplaying 3 of 6
jean schwindt
Feb 15, 2007 4:53 PM ET
"Having It All"
Survey executive women and men as to the major criteria defining "Having It All" at 25 at 35 at 45 at 55 and at 65 … more
Narendra Pulipaka
Sep 27, 2006 5:18 PM ET
What about Asians?
There are quite a few Asian (both male and female) students graduating out of Top MBA programs every year - most of … more
Jerome Kern
Jun 9, 2006 2:16 PM ET
What *women* want
I'm all for promoting women in finance or any other field, for that matter, but why does everyone believe that … more
Post a comment | View all comments