Free Subscription to CFO Magazine

You are here: Home : CFO Magazine : December 2005 Issue : Article

The Narrowing GAAP

(continued)


On the Agenda
A look at how convergence has changed, or is likely to change, particular areas of accounting, based on CFO's analysis. The arrows, though only a rough indicator, point to whichever board was more influential in the development of the standard, either because that board took the lead in developing the standard, or because the final standard adopted more-closely resembled existing U.S. GAAP or IFRS.

Completed Projects
Share-based payment FASB IASB Touted as a joint project, although FASB followed IASB's lead. Some differences in income-tax treatment remain.
Inventories FASB IASB FASB changed its accounting guidance to require all abnormal manufacturing costs to be recognized as an expense. Although essentially a minor wording change, the result moved the standard toward IFRS.
Asset exchanges FASB IASB FASB eliminated an exception to the fair-value measurement principle in existing U.S. GAAP, resulting in a standard that is simpler to apply and converged with IFRS.
Voluntary changes in accounting policies FASB IASB Requires "retrospective application" of certain voluntary changes in accounting policy, which critics complained could be confused with restatements.
Discounted activities FASB IASB Moved international accounting closer to U.S. GAAP with regard to assets held for sale and the timing of classification of operations as discontinued. FASB and IASB definitions of discontinued operations remain divergent.
Depreciation on assets held for disposal or idle assets FASB IASB Moved international accounting closer to U.S. GAAP.
Projects Under Way
Business combinations and reporting non-controlling interests FASB + IASB The first joint project in which FASB and IASB issued a common exposure draft. The principles it describes would effectively require expensing of acquistion costs, and also would be likely to eliminate many of the greatest differences currently seen when foreign issuers reconcile their accounting to U.S. GAAP.
Revenue recognition FASB + IASB The second of the two boards' joint projects. One of the primary goals is to eliminate more than 180 pieces of different, and sometimes conflicting, revenue-recognition guidance that exist in U.S. GAAP.
Financial-performance reporting FASB + IASB Replaces separate efforts by the boards to revamp the income statement. Initital definitions of "financing" follow IASB's approach, requiring companies to conform to the definition, rather than choose whether they consider income items to be derived from financing or operations.
Liabilities and equity FASB IASB Currently under development by FASB, the resulting discussion paper (on how to account for financial instruments with characteristics of both debt and equity) will be issued by IASB for comment by its constituents—an example of the modified joint approach, in which one board does the initial development work, with the goal of then proceeding as a joint project.
Insurance contracts FASB IASB Another modified joint approach project, in this case led by IASB, which views many insurance contracts as a type of financial instrument. FASB expects to issue the resulting IASB discussion paper for comment by its constituents.
Income taxes FASB IASB An exposure draft expected next year will aim to eliminate differences among existing standards. Both IASB and FASB propose to adopt elements of each other's standards.
Postretirement benefits FASB + IASB FASB added this project to its agenda last month, and proposes requiring balance sheets to reflect the status of pension funding based on the fair value of pension assets. Experts predict a joint FASB-IASB second phase will eliminate or reduce smoothing.
Major Future Projects
Leasing FASB IASB Not formally on FASB's agenda, but long expected and recently endorsed by the SEC. IASB has an active research project on the topic. Most observers expect that the boards will ultimately require all leases to be capitalized.
Intangible assets Unknown Would seek to recognize internally developed intangible assets, such as patents and copyrights, on the financial statements. IASB has an active research project on the topic.

Reader CommentsDisplaying 3 of 3

  • Horng Han Tan

    Sep 1, 2007 12:54 PM ET

    Restatement of Financial reporting (FR) in Middle East

    I read the article "Too Much GAAP Running Around" by Sarah Johnson (posted Aug 2 2007) with great interest. IN the … more

  • ramakrishnan venkitarayan

    Dec 19, 2005 2:39 PM ET

    splendid

    the article was splendid in need . although long gives a comprehensive view on convergence

  • Chandrasekar Venkataraman

    Dec 1, 2005 10:30 AM ET

    Convergence - Way to go

    The article made insightful reading. With geographies ceasing to exist and trade barriers getting eliminated slowly but … more

Post a comment | View all comments