Rules seem onerous until you contemplate life without them. That seems to be one message uncovered in a survey of more than 200 CFOs and senior comptrollers recently conducted by accounting firm Grant Thornton. Asked whether today's financial statements are too complex for the average investor, a solid majority said yes. A slim majority thought that principles-based standards that allow for professional judgment (that is, international financial reporting standards, or IFRS) would be superior to the current system of rules-based standards that offer plenty of detailed guidance (U.S. generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP). But few companies have experience in preparing financial statements based on IFRS, and only a quarter agree with the Securities and Exchange Commission's decision to allow foreign companies listed on U.S. exchanges to file statements in IFRS with no reconciliation to U.S. GAAP.



Video

Reader CommentsDisplaying 3 of 4
Roland Cycan
Jun 27, 2008 9:51 AM ET
adding to the prior comment
Not only is it the fault of the rule maker if the rules are followed and the product makes no sense, it is also the … more
Roland Cycan
Jun 27, 2008 9:48 AM ET
the fault of the rule maker
GAAP long ago drove preparers out of the mindset of preparing meaningful financial statements. Now the preparers just … more
Joe Jefferis
Jun 9, 2008 11:10 AM ET
Question Authority
How does one go about questioning the decisions of internal leaders who may have reason to make the financial … more
Post a comment | View all comments